February 20, 2026
by Carla Hay

“How to Make a Killing” (2026)
Directed by John Patton Ford
Culture Representation: Taking place in New York state and in New Jersey, the comedy/drama film “How to Make a Killing” (loosely based on the movie “Kind Hearts and Coronets” and the novel “Israel Rank: The Autobiography of a Criminal”) features a predominantly white cast of characters (with a few African Americans people and Asians) representing the working-class, middle-class and wealthy.
Culture Clash: A death-row inmate, whose execution is scheduled within the next 24 hours, tells a priest the story of how he ended up becoming a murderer who wanted to kill off all of his direct family members, in order to inherit a $28 billion fortune.
Culture Audience: “How to Make a Killing” will appeal primarily to people who are fans of the movie’s headliners and preposterous stories about pre-meditated murder.

“How to Make a Killing” starts with a shaky concept and then crumbles under the weight of its own foolishness. This unimpressive comedy/drama (about a disowned man who murders his relatives for a $28 billion inheritance) never looks believable. The last 20 minutes of the movie are especially egregious in how it throws in plot twists that make the movie a lot worse than it could’ve been.
Written and directed John Patton Ford, “How to Make a Killing” is loosely based on the 1949 film “Kind Hearts and Coronets,” which was loosely inspired by Roy Horniman’s 1907 novel “Israel Rank: The Autobiography of a Criminal.” That’s probably why many of the scenarios presented in “How to Make a Killing” (which takes place in the mid-2020s) don’t ring true in this day and age of the police investigations and media coverage being directly impacted by the Internet and modern technology. “How to Make a Killing” takes place in New York state and in New Jersey, but the movie was actually filmed in South Africa.
“How to Make a Killing” begins by showing a death-row inmate named Becket Redfellow (played by Glen Powell) having one of his last meals before his scheduled execution, which is supposed to take place within the next 24 hours. Becket, who is in his cell, is being visited by a priest named Father Morris (played by Adrian Lukis), who is there to counsel Becket and hear any last confessions.
“The real story of why I’m here is not true,” Becket tells the priest. “The real story is impressive.” Becket (who was born in 1993) has a very long confession, which takes up about 85% of the movie’s screen time. This confession is told in flashback scenes. Becket tells his life story in these scenes, which detail how he became a serial killer. The movie also shows whether or not Becket gets executed.
As these scenes play out, it becomes obvious the movie expects viewers to believe that Becket is either the luckiest serial killer to avoid arrest when he’s the prime suspect in these murders, and/or the law enforcement officials investigating him are the most incompetent law enforcement officials who could possibly investigate. Becket obviously gets arrested at some point, but it takes an awfully long time for it to happen when he’s on law enforcement’s radar for being a suspected serial killer of his relatives.
Becket explains to Father Morris that his motive to get all of his family’s $28 billion wealth is revenge for his mother being disowned from the family for being an unwed teenager when she got pregnant and gave birth to Becket. Becket’s mother Mary Estella Redfellow (played by Nell Williams) was 18 and living a privileged billionaire heiress life in Huntington, New York, when she got pregnant. At the time, the Redfellow family had a fortune worth $18 billion to $19 billion. By the end of the movie, the fortune is worth about $28 billion.
Becket’s father Gary (played by Damien Wantenaar) was about the same age as Mary. Gary was a cellist in a classical music group hired to perform at a Redfellow family party. Mary and Gary had a short-term fling, which resulted in her unplanned pregnancy. Gary died in a car crash shortly after Mary told her domineering father Whitelaw Redfellow (played by Ed Harris) about being pregnant with Gary’s child. It’s implied that Gary’s car crash was no accident.
Mary refused to have an abortion or give the baby up for adoption, so she was disowned from the family. However, all of the Redfellow family inheritance wills are required to have a clause mandating that the fortune of a deceased family member must be passed down to the closest living family members, regardless if the family members are estranged or not. It has to do with keeping the Redfellow family business (a financial services conglomerate) controlled by family members.
Mary raised boyhood Becket (played by Grady Wilson) in working-class Belleville, New Jersey. Mary has been open in telling Becket about her biological family and why she was disowned. Despite being cut off from her family’s fortune, Mary was determined to give Becket the type of education that he would’ve had if they were wealthy.
At 8 or 9 years old, Becket is seen attending an elite private school, where he meets Julia Steinway (played by Maggie Toomey), who will go on to become an influential person in Becket’s life. In childhood, Becket and Julia like each other from the start. However, Julia knows that Becket’s single mother is not wealthy, so this social-class difference causes a divide between Julia and Becket. Becket’s embarrassment about not being rich enough to impress Julia is a recurring theme whenever he interacts with Julia, even in adulthood.
Shortly after Becket and Julia meet as childhood students, Becket’s mother dies of an unnamed terminal illness. On her deathbed, Mary tells Becket: “Promise you won’t quit until you have the right kind of life, the life you deserve.” Becket was put into the foster care system until he was 18 years old. The movie doesn’t show him as a foster child or when he was in his teens and 20s.
The movie’s flashbacks fast-forward to Becket in his mid-30s. He’s working as a clerk in an upscale New York City tailor shop called David Sinclair when Julia (played by Margaret Qualley) walks into the shop. Becket and Julia haven’t seen each other since they were children, but Julia immediately remembers Becket, who still feels some embarrassment about not being rich enough to impress Julia.
However, there’s an attraction between them, so Becket asks Julia out for a drink. Julia politely declines because she says she’s engaged to be married. Becket feels even more embarrassed because he didn’t notice Julia’s engagement ring until she showed him.
Based on the type of diamond ring it is, it looks like Julia’s soon-to-be husband can afford to give Julia the lifestyle to which she’s become accustomed. Julia is engaged to a businessman named Lyle Archdale (played by James Frecheville), who was a classmate student at the same school that Becket and Julia attended when Becket and Julia met. Julia tells Becket that after spending some time living overseas, she’s now settled down in Montclair, New Jersey.
After being rejected by Julia, Becket decides he’s going to fulfill his mother’s dying wish. However, his mother Mary never told Becket to kill off his remaining family members to inherit the family fortune. That was Becket’s own warped decision and his twisted way of getting “the right kind of life.”
The majority of “How to Make a Killing” shows how Becket plotted and schemed to murder his remaining direct family members. These are the relatives who are on Becket’s hit list:
- Ted Redfellow (played by Raff Law), Becket’s youngest cousin, is a spoiled and hard-partying financial broker who works for the family’s company.
- Warren Redfellow (played by Bill Camp), Becket’s second-oldest uncle/Ted’s father, seems to be the only ethical and kind person in the family.
- Noah Redfellow (played by Zach Woods), Becket’s middle-oldest cousin, is a fame-hungry painter artist who markets himself on social media.
- Steven Redfellow (played by Topher Grace), Becket’s oldest cousin, is an unscrupulous pastor leader of a megachurch.
- Cassandra Redfellow (played by Bianca Amato), Becket’s aunt, is not in the movie long enough to show her personality, but she gives the impression of being shallow and vain.
- McArthur Redfellow (played by Alexander Hanson), Becket’s oldest uncle, is also briefly seen in the movie as he shows off while flying his own small private plane.
- Whitelaw Redfellow, Becket’s maternal grandfather, is the cruel patriarch responsible for exiling Mary from the family.
It’s not spoiler information to say that Becket commits murder because it’s established from the beginning of the film that Becket is on death row for being a murderer. However, this review won’t reveal how any of the Redfellow family members die and in which order. It’s enough to say that not all of the family members die by murder.
After his cousin Ted’s death, Becket introduces himself to Ted’s father Warren and reveals himself to be Mary’s child. Warren and Mary were siblings who used to be very close until she was exiled from the family. A grieving Warren is immediately accepting of Becket. Warren always hated the decision to disown Mary, so he gives Becket a job at the family’s company. Warren begins to treat Becket like a surrogate son.
Becket rises through the ranks at the company and becomes emotionally attached to Warren, the person in the family whom Becket is the most reluctant to kill. Becket eventually makes enough money at the company to become comfortably affluent, but that’s not enough for him. Becket still wants the entire family fortune for himself.
Becket also gets himself into an emotionally tricky situation when Noah’s girlfriend Ruth (played by Jessica Henwick) becomes romantically involved with Becket after Noah’s death. Becket is the one who pursued her after Noah died. Becket and Ruth had an instant attraction to each other when they met while Noah was still alive. Becket and Ruth bonded with each over their nerdy passion for literature. Dimwitted and superficial Noah scoffed at Ruth and Becket for being pretentious intellectuals.
At the time that Ruth and Becket met, Ruth was working for a denim company and going to school to become a literature teacher for high school students. The trailer for “How to Make a Killing” already reveals that Becket and Ruth become a couple. The movie shows what happens to their relationship and how Ruth handled Becket being convicted of murder and given a death sentence.
Meanwhile, married Julia pops in and out of Becket’s life and continues to flirt with him. She eventually reveals to Becket that her husband Lyle was dishonest with her about how much money he has. Lyle is actually finanically broke, but Julia (a socialite who doesn’t work) doesn’t want to divorce Lyle because she’s too proud to publicly admit she was conned and is in a dire financial situation. Julia’s greed and obsession with being wealthy are motives for what she does in the story.
With so many Redfellow family members dying in a relatively short period of time, it doesn’t take a genius to see who would benefit from inheriting the Redfellow family fortune. Becket also has the means and the opportunity (no alibi) for these murders, since he was in close proximity during all of the family member deaths that happened in the story. And yet, “How to Make a Killing” is quite pathetic in showing how Becket doesn’t get nearly the amount of scrutiny that he would in real life.
Only two FBI agents—Megan Pinfield (played by Phumi Tau) and Brad Matthews (played by Stevel Marc)—contact Becket to interview him and to let him know that he’s under investigation for these deaths in the Redfellow family. These two FBI agents are not seen again for long stretches of the movie before they show up again. There are no indications that Becket is under any type of surveillance. This lack of scrutiny emboldens Becket to plot more murders. Julia gets suspicious of Becket and has better investigative skills than the law enforcement in this movie.
“How to Make a Killing” also completely ignores the reality that all these deaths in an extremely wealthy family would get a lot of media attention. In this situation, Becket would definitely be the focus of that media attention, as the body count increases, but that type of media probe never happens in this brain-dead movie. A few of the deaths are made to look like accidents, but at least one death cannot be ruled as an accident and is definitely murder.
Even so, all these deaths in one very wealthy family would be enough for a large-scale investigation and intense media exposure. Becket shows no signs of physical aging in the parts of the story where he’s an adult, which is how you know that the murders happen within a relatively short period of time—four years or less. Two of the deaths happen so quickly, they’re shown in less than two minutes each in the movie.
Becket’s death-row execution timeline is also handled unrealistically. Even the most notorious serial killers on death row don’t get executed within a year or two after their prison sentencing, because most of these death-row prisoners use the appeals process to delay their executions. But there Becket is on death row, looking the same way that he did when he started becoming a serial killer.
In other words, “How to Make a Killing” is not only lazy and idiotic in crafting a story but also in the movie’s technical aspects. It wouldn’t have been difficult for the movie’s makeup and hairstyling departments to make Becket look older when he was on death row. The timeline for this story is so truncated, the plot twists that come in fast and loose toward the end of the movie look like something a child would fabricate when a child doesn’t know how to finish a story.
Powell has seemed to make a career out of playing smirking rebels and bad boys. “How to Make a Killing” is just more of the same typecasting for him. In the role of Julia, Qualley is portraying yet another seductress with her own agenda. There are fleeting moments that are genuinely funny, mostly in scenes with Woods as insecure attention-seeker Noah, and Grace as entitled jerk/con artist Steven. However, the rest of the movie’s supporting cast members play it straight with the very stereotyped characters that they’ve been given in this disappointing movie.
“How to Make a Killing” also has a condescending and off-putting message at the end, where Becket (in a voiceover) makes a preachy comment that viewers will probably be upset because the movie’s ending is not what most viewers are expecting because people have been programmed to think a certain way about crime, punishment and morality. It’s a comment made with a smug filmmaker tone that seems to be saying, “We’re smarter than the average viewer.” Actually, viewers usually don’t get upset by unconventional endings. Viewers get upset when they’ve wasted their time watching a cynical, dull and creatively barren movie like “How to Make a Killing.”
A24 released “How to Make a Killing” in U.S. cinemas on February 20, 2026. A sneak preview of the movie was shown in U.S. cinemas on February 17, 2026.










