October 15, 2025
by Carla Hay

Directed by Edward Burns
Culture Representation: Taking place in New York City, the comedy film “The Family McMullen” (a sequel to the 1995 movie “The Brothers McMullen”) features a predominantly white cast of characters (with a few mixed-race African Americans) representing the working-class, middle-class and wealthy.
Culture Clash: Thanksgiving dinner with the unlucky-in-love McMullen family sets off a chain of events that might or might not improve the romance luck for certain members of the family.
Culture Audience: “The Family McMullen” will appeal primarily to people who are fans of 1995’s “The Brothers McMullen”; filmmaker/actor Edward Burns and the movie’s other headliners; and lightweight romantic comedies with mostly good performances.
As a follow-up to the 1995 comedy/drama “The Brothers McMullen,” “The Family McMullen” doesn’t really need to exist, but this movie could’ve been a lot worse than the formulaic film it turned out to be. It’s not a complete waste of time for people already expecting “The Family McMullen” to not be as witty and original as “The Brothers McMullen,” which won the 1995 Sundance Film Festival’s grand jury prize in the U.S. Dramatic Competition. “The Brothers McMullen” was also the first movie released by the company then known as Fox Searchlight Pictures and is now known as Searchlight Pictures. Filmmaker/co-star Edward Burns serves up another mix of sarcasm and sentimentality in this comedy sequel. Taking place during the November-December holiday season, the movie is like reheated comfort food for people who are in the mood for it.
Written and directed by Burns, “The Family McMullen” takes place during three or four weeks in New York City, with an epilogue taking place one year after the main story. (“The Family McMullen” was filmed in New York City and in New Jersey.) “The Family McMullen” has a much more lighthearted tone than “The Brothers McMullen,” which delved more into the angst-ridden fraternal relationship between the title characters. “The Family McMullen” also has the look and story of a made-for-TV movie, which might be why Warner Bros. Pictures opted not to give “The Family McMullen” a regular theatrical release and instead gave the movie a one-day-only release in U.S. theaters through Fathom Entertainment.
There’s a slickness to “The Family McMullen” that might turn off some viewers who are big fans of “The Brothers McMullen.” “The Brothers McMullen” (which took place in the mid-1990s and was Burns’ feature-film directorial debut) is about three tight-knit Irish American Catholic brothers in their 20s, as they navigate various challenges and problems in their love lives. Some of the acting performances in “The Brothers McMullen” were amateurish, by the movie’s screenplay and direction had scrappy charm.
In “The Brothers McMullen,” the family’s patriarch has died in the beginning of the story, his widow has moved back to Ireland to be with a former childhood sweetheart, and the three sons left behind in New York lean on each other emotionally, for better or for worse. Eldest brother Jack McMullen (played Jack Mulcahy), who has purchased the family home in the Long Island village of Valley Stream, is cheating on his wife Molly McMullen (played by Connie Britton) and decides if he will leave Molly for his mistress Ann (played by Elizabeth McKay). Jack’s two younger brothers temporarily move in with Jack in the family home due to transitions in their personal lives.
Middle brother Finbar “Barry” McMullen (played by Burns) is commitment-phobic and is unsure of how to handle dating his new girlfriend Audrey (played by Maxine Bahns), who wants a relationship that’s more than casual. Youngest brother Patrick McMullen (played by Michael McGlone) and his fiancée Susan (played by Shari Albert) have an on-again/off-again relationship, which is made more complicated when Patrick becomes attracted to another woman named Leslie (played by Jennifer Jostyn). The end of the movie shows what happens to all of the brothers’ love relationships.
Is it necessary to see or at least know about “The Brothers McMullen” before seeing “The Family McMullen”? Probably, because this knowledge goes a long way in explaining the context and previous histories of the older adults in “The Family McMullen.” The beginning of “The Family McMullen” also reveals the ending of “The Brothers McMullen” because enough time has passed, and there are updates to what has happened since the end of the story in “The Brothers McMullen.” Four of “The Brothers McMullen” principal cast members (Burns, McGlone, Britton and Albert) reprise the same character roles in “The Family McMullen.”
“The Family McMullen,” which takes place 30 years after the events of “The Brothers McMullen,” begins with the McMullen family gathered for Thanksgiving dinner at Barry’s house in New York City’s Brooklyn borough. Eldest brother Jack, who decided to stay in his marriage to Molly, died of cancer not too long ago. Jack and Molly did not have children. Molly still lives in the McMullen childhood house where she and Jack lived during most of their marriage. The house, which Molly inherited after Jack’s death, has a lot of painful memories for Molly, so she wants to sell the house.
Barry is now a twice-divorced father of two children in their mid-to-late 20s: freewheeling and confident Tommy (played by Pico Alexander) and prim and insecure Patty (played by Halston Sage), who are both at this Thanksgiving dinner. The unnamed mother of Tommy and Patty is Barry’s second ex-wife, who lives in Miami. Barry and his unnamed first ex-wife didn’t have children. Barry cheated on his first ex-wife with the woman who became his second ex-wife.
Patrick, who moved to California to be with Leslie, ended up marrying her and had children with her. These children are now adults and are not seen in the movie. Patrick (who owns and operates a brewery) is now separated from Leslie, who asked him to move out of their home because she’s no longer in love with Patrick. Unlike Barry, who is a non-practicing Catholic, Patrick is a very religious Catholic who feels guilty that he’s probably going to get divorced. Temporarily homeless Patrick asks to move in with Barry for about a month while Patrick tries to recover from the heartbreak of his marital separation. Barry reluctantly agrees to this request.
It’s not really clear what Barry does for a living because no one (except for a plumber named Sam Dukakis; more about him later) who is a McMullen family member or a love interest for a McMullen family member is actually shown working in any job in this movie. “The Family McMullen” revolves entirely around what is going on in the love lives of the McMullen family members. The movie gets a bit lazy in how it recycles reasons why certain hookups or potential romances happen: Four of the would-be couples were each other’s crushes when they were schoolmates, and they get reacquainted during the movie.
Tommy is commitment-phobic and cynical about love, which means—in true rom-com fashion—he’s going to fall madly in love with someone at some point in the movie—just like Barry did in “The Brothers McMullen.” Tommy, who was living in California, decides he’s moving to New York to become an actor. Tommy temporarily moves in with Barry, which mirrors “The Brothers McMullen” storyline of Barry and Patrick moving in with their older brother Jack.
Patty’s storyline is almost a rehash of Patrick’s on-again/off-again engagement story arc in “The Brothers McMullen.” In the beginning of “The Family McMullen,” Patty is engaged to a former law school classmate named Terrence Joseph (played by Bryan Fitzgerald), who arrives late for this Thanksgiving dinner. Barry and Molly don’t like Terrence Joseph because they think Terrence Joseph is pretentious and phony. Barry privately calls Terrence Joseph a “wannabe blue blood” because Terrence Joseph is an Irish American Catholic who tries to act like a WASP (White Anglo Saxon Protestant) as a social climber.
Terrence Joseph (who dislikes being called T.J., but Barry calls him T.J. anyway) also alienated Barry because Patty and Terrence Joseph announced their engagement as a surprise at the Thanksgiving dinner. Barry openly expresses resentment to Terrence Joseph that Terrence Joseph didn’t ask for Barry’s blessing for this marriage proposal. Barry says at the dinner table that if Barry were a strict traditionalist, he would want to take Terrence Joseph out for a fight because Terrence Joseph snubbed Barry about this tradition of asking the potential father-in-law for approval in marrying the father’s daughter.
After Patty and Terrence Joseph announce their engagement, Barry and Molly react by telling the couple to seriously reconsider getting married. Molly comments on her own troubled marriage to Jack, by saying that she regrets that she and Jack didn’t have more dating experience before getting married. Molly says that Jack might not have cheated on her if Jack had a chance to have sex with more women before getting married.
Terrence Joseph thinks there’s a lot of validity to that belief, so he tells Patty they should have a trial separation for about a month, during which they can date other people and figure out if they still want to get married to each other. Patty (who was a virgin until she dated Terrence Joseph) hates the idea of a trial separation, so she breaks up with Terrence Joseph. However, Patty remains conflicted about the breakup because she’s afraid of being alone and leaves open the possibility that she could get back together with Terrence Joseph. And just like her uncle Patrick, Patty temporarily moves in with Barry because she has nowhere else to live after a breakup.
On Thanksgiving night, Barry and Tommy are hanging out at a bar named Farrell’s when Tommy has his “meet cute” moment with an opinionated and independent woman named Karen (played by Juliana Canfield), who has just broken up with her boyfriend (played by John El-Jor), who is sobbing at a table in the bar. Karen is ordering a drink when Tommy strikes up a conversation with her and incorrectly guesses that she’s not a native New Yorker. She was actually born and raised in Brooklyn, just like Tommy was. Karen and Tommy have a short back-and-forth conversation where Tommy tries to flirt with her, but she rejects his advances.
On another day, Tommy sees Karen walking on a street and convinces her to have lunch with him. It’s during this lunch date that Karen tells Tommy that she’s never been in love and isn’t looking to be in a serious relationship. Tommy says he feels the same way. And you know what that means in a romantic comedy like this one. A recurring joke in the movie is that Karen and Tommy bond over quoting lines from the 1990 Mafia drama “Goodfellas.”
Molly and Jack didn’t have a great marriage, so her widow’s grief isn’t as excruciating as it would be if she and Jack had a healthy relationship. And that’s why, when Molly unexpectedly runs into a widower former high school classmate named Walter (played by Brian d’Arcy James), the romantic sparks that they had in high school are still there. However, Molly isn’t completely ready to jump into another relationship when she and Walter get reacquainted. Just by coincidence, Walter is a real-estate agent, so Molly hires him to sell her house.
Patrick unexpectedly gets reacquainted with his ex-fiancée Susan, a former high school classmate who is now a divorced mother of adult children. Patrick and Susan see each other again when she is in the waiting room of a psychotherapist named Dr. Sal Sabatino (played by Stephen Badalamenti) when Patrick has an appointment with the doctor. Sal’s counseling style is too casual for Patrick, so Patrick’s first counseling session with Sal turns out to be the last one that Patrick has with Sal. Susan is a client of Sal’s and initiates reconnecting with Patrick. The movie briefly hints that Patrick could be somewhat attracted to his former sister-in-law Molly, but developing that storyline would be too messy for “The Family McMullen,” which is determined to have every storyline tied up in a neat little bow.
During Patty’s trial separation, a former high school classmate named Sam Dukakis (played by Sam Vartholomeos), who works for his family-owned Dukakis Plumbing, comes over to Barry’s house to fix a toilet. Patty happens to be brushing her teeth in the bathroom when Sam arrives. Sam (who is an available bachelor) and Patty were each other’s first kiss. They had crushes on each other when they were schoolmates, but nothing ever came of it. And you can easily guess what that means when they reconnect as adults.
But unless you think that’s all of the “blast from the past” potential romances in “The Family McMullen,” think again, because there’s one more. After Karen and Tommy begin dating, they find out that Karen’s divorced mother Nina Martin (played by Tracee Ellis Ross) and Tommy’s father Barry have known each other since high school and have had on-again/off-again flings with each other for years. Can you say “awkward family situation”? This complication bothers everyone except Barry, who thinks it’s kind of hilarious.
“The Family McMullen” gets a little overstuffed with these types contrivances. However, what saves the movie and makes it watchable is how most of the principal cast members are able to skillfully handle the movie’s verbose and fast-paced dialogue. Burns, Britton, McGlone, Ross, Alexander, Canfield and James all have great comedic timing in delivering their lines and in their body language. Sage isn’t quite up to the same level of talent, as she strains to be funny in ways that are uncomfortable to watch.
The young people’s romances are hit and miss in the movie. Tommy and Karen are a believable couple, thanks to talented performances from Alexander and Canfield. It helps that they both play characters who are very self-aware of their shortcomings. The storyline of whiny Patty and self-centered Terrence Joseph quickly becomes tiresome, and the late entrance of Sam in the story doesn’t do much to spark enthusiasm. Meanwhile, the characters of Molly and Walter don’t get as much screen time as they should.
A major flaw in “The Family McMullen” screenplay is more variety was needed in how these potential couples know each other. Can’t these people find anyone else to date besides their former schoolmates? New York City is the largest city in the United States—not a small town with limited options. It’s a failure of imagination to have the “unrequited crush from high school” as the basis of too many possible romances in this movie.
As it is, “The Family McMullen” is a mixed bag, just like most of Burns’ movies. Some of the dialogue is laugh-out-loud funny and interesting, while some of the dialogue is stale and cringeworthy. (The movie’s last scene is especially treacly.) If not for the engaging way that this dialogue is performed by most of the cast, “The Family McMullen” would be hard to watch because its frequent triteness lowers the quality of the movie.
Fathom Entertainment released “The Family McMullen” for a one-day-only limited engagement in U.S. cinemas on October 15, 2025. HBO Max will premiere “The Family McMullen” on December 5, 2025.






