November 28, 2025
by Carla Hay

Directed by Michael J. Weithorn
Culture Representation: Taking place in New York City, the comedy/drama film “The Best You Can” features a predominantly white cast of characters (with a few African Americans, Latin people and Asians) representing the working-class and middle-class.
Culture Clash: A divorced security guard and an unhappily married urologist develop an unlikely friendship and growing romantic feelings for each other, as the urologist’s husband has failing health.
Culture Audience: “The Best You Can” will appeal primarily to people who are fans of the movie’s headliners and comedy/drama movies about people who find love in middle-age.

“The Best You Can” is a predictable but appealing comedy/drama about a divorced security guard and an unhappily married urologist whose unlikely friendship turns into something more. The performances and amusing banter are the main reasons to watch. This is the type of movie where you know how the story will end within the first 15 minutes of watching. The trailer for “The Best You Can” also gives away about 85% of the movie’s plot.
Written and directed by Michael J. Weithorn, “The Best You Can” had its world premiere at the 2025 Tribeca Festival. The movie takes place in New York City, where “The Best You Can” was filmed on location. “The Best You Can” is the first movie that real-life spouses Kevin Bacon and Kyra Sedgwick have co-starred in together since 2004’s “The Woodsman.” Bacon and Sedwick (who’ve been married since 1988) are also two of the producers of “The Best You Can.”
The concept for “The Best You Can” is fairly simple, but it gets stretched by a lot of the up-and-down relationships and ambivalent feelings that the main characters experience with each other. Dr. Cynthia Rand (played by Sedgwick), the urologist in this story, is stuck in a crumbling marriage to retired attorney Warren Rand (played by Judd Hirsch), who is 83 years old. Cynthia met Warren when she was in her early 30s, and he was 57. They do not have any children together.
Warren was the assistant chief counsel to the committee that investigated the Watergate scandal in 1973. It’s Warren’s main claim to fame. He’s been trying for years to get a book published about his Watergate experience. His latest manuscript has been rejected by a book publisher, which considers the book’s topic to be irrelevant to today’s book consumers.
Cynthia, who is now in her late 50s, is Warren’s second wife. He divorced his first wife to be with Cynthia. It’s implied that Cynthia and Warren fell in love and started their affair while Warren was married to his first wife. Warren has a middle-aged adult daughter named Rosemary (played by Heather Burns) from his first marriage.
Not surprisingly, Rosemary (who is only 12 years younger than Cynthia) doesn’t like Cynthia because Rosemary blames Cynthia for the breakup of Warren’s first marriage. Luckily for Cynthia, she doesn’t have to see Rosemary very often because Rosemary (who is a married mother of a tween-age son) lives in Phoenix. Even with this long distance between Cynthia and her stepdaughter Rosemary, the two women still have a tense relationship.
The marriage of Cynthia and Warren is dying because Cynthia has fallen out of love with him. Warren can be cranky and demanding, but he isn’t abusive. Cynthia is starting to have doubts about their age-gap marriage, as well as regrets about her and Warren’s decision not to have children together. Cynthia worries that she doesn’t have much to show for her life except for her career, a comfortable place to live, and a marriage to a man she no longer loves.
There are indications that Warren has dementia. Cynthia privately admits to herself that she’s not emotionally equipped to be Warren’s caregiver. She thinks she’s still young enough to deserve to be in a passionate and vital marriage. However, Cynthia doesn’t want to divorce Warren out of loyalty and because she is the type of person who doesn’t like to admit failure.
Meanwhile, Stan Olszewski (played by Bacon), who is in his mid-to-late 60s, knows all about failure in personal relationships. He’s a divorced dad who is estranged from his 20-year-old daughter Sammi (played by Brittany O’Grady) because he was an absentee father for most of Sammi’s life. Stan and his ex-wife (Sammi’s mother) got divorced when Sammi was 10 years old. After the divorce, Stan lived for two years in Colorado before moving back to New York. During the course of the story, Stan tries to reconnect with Sammi, who is an aspiring singer/songwriter.
Stan is a former police officer who now works for a company called Brooklyn Private Security Patrol, where his job is to drive around neighborhoods for safety checks and to respond to any calls for security protection. In the beginning of the movie, Stan is in a medical exam, where he has been diagnosed with having an enlarged prostate, a medical condition that causes the urge to urinate more often than usual. He is prescribed Flomax and is urged to see a urologist soon, or else his enlarged prostate could result in prostate cancer.
Because of his enlarged prostate, Stan urinates on strangers’ lawns while he’s working. Because he works at night, people usually don’t see him committing this crime. One night, Stan responds to an intruder alert at the home of Cynthia and Warren. It’s a false alarm, but Stan stays a while because he asks to use the restroom in the couple’s house. When Stan mentions that he often has to urinate, Cynthia correctly assumes that Stan has an enlarged prostate. She tells Stan that she’s a urologist and gives him her business card.
Stan makes an appointment with Cynthia, but he doesn’t have enough health insurance to cover the cost of the exam. Cynthia offers to give a price discount to Stan through a “friends and family” medical discount plan that her job provides. Stan is grateful. He and Cynthia start talking about their personal lives and find out that they both have the same birthdate: December 24.
Cynthia and Stan exchange their private contact information. They communicate with each other mostly online and sometimes through phone conversations. It’s the start of a platonic friendship. They flirt a little, and then flirt some more. And it isn’t long before Stan and Cynthia have romantic feelings for each other that neither person wants to admit to right away.
The tentative romance of Stan and Cynthia is a stereotypical case of “opposites attract.” Stan likes to get drunk and smoke marijuana. He admits to Cynthia that he was a hellraiser in his youth, when he was arrested at least once. Cynthia has a history of experimenting with drugs, but she’s a lot more health-conscious than Sam. She likes to keeps her life orderly, in contrast to Stan, who’s accustomed to his life being a bit of a mess.
“The Best You Can” rolls along like a reliable vintage car, with some subplots that elongate the journey along the way. Shortly after Stan meets Cynthia, he begins a “friends with benefits” relationship with a free-spirited grocery store cashier named CJ Moretti (played by Olivia Luccardi), who’s about 30 years younger than Stan. Even though Cynthia has no right to be possessive of Stan, she’s jealous of his relationship with CJ and is offended that he’s dating a woman who’s young enough to be his daughter. Cynthia’s attitude is very hypocritical because Cynthia and Warren have a big age gap in their relationship too.
In a typical sitcom-ish scenario, Cynthia finds herself on a “double date” dinner with Warren, Stan and CJ, for reasons that are shown in the movie. There’s also a somewhat unnecessary subplot of Warren having trouble finding a reliable assistant to help him with his book. And there’s some drama because Rosemary and her family are moving from Phoenix to Cleveland, where Rosemary wants to put Warren in an assisted-care facility.
“The Best You Can” has moments that are very cliché, but the acting is solid and engaging. Because they are married in real life, Bacon and Sedgwick have an easy chemistry with each other that makes the romance between Stan and Cynthia very believable, even though it’s questionable how long the romance between Stan and Cynthia can really last. The supporting cast members (including Ray Romano as Cynthia’s doctor colleague Doug) give perfectly fine performances, but nothing about “The Best You Can” is award-worthy.
The movie doesn’t gloss over the moral dilemmas of an extramarital affair, but “The Best You Can” reaches a conclusion that makes this affair less ethically problematic. (Think of the most obvious thing that could happen, and that’s what happens.) “The Best You Can” can be commended for tackling difficult subject matter (what can happen to a love-starved spouse who’s stuck in a moribund marriage to someone in ill health) that usually isn’t seen in most movies about romantic love. “The Best You Can” doesn’t do anything groundbreaking, but it offers some bittersweet and candid moments showing there’s no age limit on experiencing the awkwardness and thrills of a new romance.
Sony Pictures Home Entertainment released “The Best You Can” on digital and VOD on November 25, 2025. Netflix will premiere the movie on December 25, 2025.




